Vintage and Antique Engagement Rings Are Trending

Vintage and antique engagement rings are considered by some to evoke vibes of romantic nostalgia and are considered an homage to the historical charm of bygone eras. Others love the precise details of vintage and antique ring designs that are not as commonly found in modern engagement rings. Vintage or antique rings also appeal to couples who are searching for something a bit more distinctive. Whatever your reasons are, always consider all the pros and cons before choosing a vintage or antique engagement ring.

Pro #1: Vintage Engagement Rings Offer An Excellent Bargain Without Sacrificing Quality, Detail, Or Stone Size.

Older diamonds, on average, cost about 30 percent less than new diamonds. Vintage engagement ring settings are approximately half the cost of new settings since they are preowned. Vintage or antique jewelry is also VAT-exempt (Value-Added Tax.) This exemption typically makes engagement rings cost around 20 percent less than new engagement rings, and the lack of manufacturing fees reduces the overall price, giving the buyer a superb value.

Pro #2: Buying A Vintage Or Antique Engagement Ring Is A Sound Investment.

Vintage engagement rings are worth much more than the materials used to craft them. Although they cost less than new engagement rings, the actual value of vintage engagement rings is higher due to their unique and refined craftsmanship, much like vintage autos. Antique-cut diamonds are collectibles as well.

Pro # 3: Because Vintage And Antique Engagement Rings Are Handmade, They Have An Unrivaled, Unique, and Hand-Crafted Flair.

Vintage and antique engagement rings often showcase an impressive level of intricate craftsmanship, offering a sophisticated precision not commonly found in modern engagement rings. Contemporary engagement rings tend to emphasize the size of the diamond; however, with vintage or antique engagement rings, the design and unique artistry makes them special and sets them apart. Vintage engagement rings usually have exquisite attributes such as meticulous milgrain detailing, pierced openwork, carved shanks, and calibré-cut accent stones that are not as commonly found in modern engagement rings.

Pro # 4: Vintage Engagement Rings Are More Sustainable.

Since no mining or production is required, buying an antique engagement ring helps to reduce your carbon footprint. Another eco-conscious option is to buy an heirloom diamond or a lab-grown diamond and have it placed in a new, vintage-style ring setting.

As appealing as all these qualities may sound, there are some caveats to keep in mind.

Con #1: Antique Diamonds Lack The Brilliance Of Modern Diamonds.

Vintage or antique diamonds may not have the same intense sparkle and shine as modern diamonds. Older diamonds were cut with larger facets, showing less light reflection than newer diamonds. The diamond edges may have become worn over the years, further diminishing brightness; this, however, can be improved a bit with a good cleaning but will generally not compare to the brilliant shine of a modern diamond. To get around this issue, having a modern diamond put into a vintage-style setting will give you all the allure of an antique ring with the radiance of a modern stone.

Con #2: For Those Seeking A Completely Colorless Diamond, A Vintage Diamond May Not Be To Their Liking.

Vintage diamonds often have warmer tones, harkening back to an era when diamonds with hints of yellow or brown were the style preference. Many view these diamonds as lesser quality, but that is not accurate. The warmer tones represent a difference in jewelry trends throughout history. 

Con #3: Vintage Or Antique Engagement Rings Require Higher Maintenance.

Due to their detailed, hand-crafted fabrication, vintage or antique engagement rings are more of a challenge to clean by hand, and cleaning a vintage ring with an ultrasonic machine is not recommended. More repairs may also be necessary due to loosened settings and general wear and tear. Those repairs often cost more than the repair of newer rings.

Con #4: Finding a Matching Wedding Band For A Vintage Or Antique Engagement Ring Might Be A Challenge.

Due to the uniqueness of each particular ring design, finding a matching wedding band can seem almost impossible. However, there is always an option for couples to have a wedding band custom designed to coordinate with their vintage engagement ring of choice. At Ritani, we offer custom-designed wedding bands. If you are interested in this option, our designers will generate a detailed 3D rendering at no additional cost. To get started, call customer service at 1-888-9RITANI or email [email protected] for further details.

If you adore the look of vintage and antique engagement rings but prefer a modern cut diamond with a more intense sparkle, check out our extensive selection of vintage-style engagement ring settings.